How to Build a Compelling Email Offer

A compelling offer that delivers true value to your current or potential customers is an essential component of any marketing strategy. But it’s even more important in acquisition email marketing, where you’ve yet to develop a relationship with the recipient of your marketing emails.

At first glance, building a compelling offer can seem daunting, but it’s really a matter of researching your customer and capitalizing on their pain points in a unique way.  Here are five steps to get you started with your offer development initiatives.

  1. Know your customer. Understanding your customers is the first step in developing an offer that they’re going to like. What kind of products are they interested in? Have they bought a product like yours recently or ever? Have they visited one of your brick and mortar stores? These are just some of the questions you should ask before developing an offer. The answers will determine the “bribe” of your offer. Will it be content, a free consultation, or a discount?  
  2. Key in on your customers’ pain points. What kind of market pain is your potential customer feeling and how does your product cure that pain? This question ties nicely with step one. Understanding exactly what your potential customers’ frustrations are, and how your product fits into that picture, serves as excellent criteria to judge your offer against.
  3. Understand the competition. Study the competition.  What kind of offers do your competitors send to their customers?  Understanding the competition can help you develop a unique offer that better resonates with your customers even though your product/services may be similar to another company’s.
  4. Know best practices.  Gain a thorough understanding of best practices as they relate acquisition email marketing. There are a number of criteria related to copy, design, and coding that can make or break the success of your campaign. We have plenty of great resources that can help you with best practices, but if you want a more hands on approach, contact Marketfish Creative Solutions. 
  5. Test and measure. As we’ve said before, acquisition email is a process of testing and refining until the desired results are achieved. The same notion applies to your offers. Create several and run smaller test campaigns. As you test your offers, be sure to test across the usual factors like subject-line, design, and audience. Once you know the combination of factors that’s most effective, roll out a larger campaign.   

I hope you found these steps helpful. Developing a compelling offer can present one of marketing’s greatest challenges. But gaining a detailed understanding of your customer and the competition is a great start to continued success with your acquisition marketing campaigns. And remember, always test, measure, and refine the results.

Now it’s your turn.  How do you go about building offers for your email and direct mail acquisition campaigns? 

Thoughts on Spring Cleaning

Yesterday, Tal Nathan of StrongMail published an excellent column in ClickZ that details his advice for reinvigorating your email program for spring.  While I agree with everything he said, there is a point I’d like to add and a section that I’d like to expound upon.

  • Creative Redesign – Tal mentions that spring is a great time to refresh your email templates.  And when you do so, expect to see a 25% lift in engagement for up to three months.  He also touches on using analysis to steer your redesign efforts.  Good stuff.  I’d just like to add that continually applying a multivariate testing strategy that accounts for tone, copy, layout, and CTA with each every campaign is a solid approach. Continually working to redesign email templates based on sound analytics will result in optimum performance and ROI, and it’s something you can do all year long.
  • Clean Your House File – Since spring cleaning is the tenor of the day, why not clean your house file while you’re at it?  Look for names that haven’t engaged in months, and implement Tal’s reengagement campaign.  When you know a contact is dead, remove them from your list.  You should also remove any opt-outs you might have missed with your first sweep.  Ideally, you’re going through this cleaning process more frequently than once every spring.  Doing so will protect your sender reputation, and leave you with a file of only your engaged recipients.   If you don’t have the resources to do this yourself, there are a number of companies that specialize in this service.  

I hope you’ll consider adding these strategies to Tal’s already excellent approach.  For the full text of his column, head here.

What other “spring cleaning” advice do you have for email marketers looking to reinvigorate their email programs?